Your argument is rudimentary. A QB that took a team to the playoffs...must be good then. Lol
I already broke it down for you...compared statistics of Tebow to the players you listed and you just shrug it off.
What did Tebow do for Denver???
You want to talk like Tebow got Denver in the playoffs but what were you saying when Chicago was 10-5 under Orton?
Or when Orton had Denver out to a 6-0 start in 2009?
As bad as Orton has become, Tebow doesn't even come close to his level and that's a testament to how much of a joke Tebow is at the QB position.
What does Tebow bring to the table with regards to the ability to play the QB position? If someone else had put up these sorry ass numbers and played like a high school QB, they wouldn't even get this amount of attention.
You didn't see Sanchez do anything? Lol double standard much? Here we have sorry ass Sanchez "leading" his team to the AFC championship but Tim Tebow's FIRST ROUND luck trumps that obviously. Dude had the lowest completion percentage in the NFL! lulz
You haven't even begun to break down anything. Tebow cannot play the position and it's been proven every season.
You cant compare Ortons play from Chi town and denver in 09 to tebow because Tebow didnt play with those guys. Yea he started 6-0 and ended 2-8 dont leave that out. When Orton and Tebow played for the same team, with the same guys, and the same coach Tebow did more with that team and took them to the playoffs.
You are right my argument is rudimentary, its basic is the simple fact that Tebow did more with the same team as orton and more than any of the guys that we talked about (excluding Sanchez like I said who had a top 5 defense each time they went anywhere in the playoffs) In your last post above this one ^^you said when people claim tebow is a good qb, I have been saying from the start I dont say he is a good qb, but he is as a viable option to start a game as a third of the league was last year that simple. So if your gonna call blaine gabbert a good qb, then yes I guess I am saying Tebow is good, but we both know damn well that isnt the truth. However, I'm saying that if Gabbert is the starting qb option on a team Tebow is just as good an option.
He might not be a good qb, but with all the other things he brings to the table he gives you a better chance of winning than a third of the starters did last year then yes I have to say he is the better option at qb than those guys. Point to padded stats all you want of those guys that get garbage time stats when their team is getting blown out by 20, Tebow threw on average about 200 less passes than any of those guys and if you scrap the one bad game against BUF he had he had 11 td's and only 3 int's,(12 and 6 if you count it) that is a great ratio. Better than any of the guys we already talked about. In the 4th quarter his completion jumps up 11% had 6 of his 12 passing tds in the fourth and 3 of his 5 rushing td in the fourth. So on top of playing clutch if you actually watched the game you would see that the broncos game plan would always change in the 4th because they played [expletive] foot ball the first three quarters and when they gave Tebow the offense in the fourth he ran it, and ran it well. You can pull out all the stats you want about the guy I watched the streak, every minuet of it, I know what the FO was trying to do and get Tebow out of there since he was drafted by the guys that were no longer there so they wanted to get rid of him.
Edited by PhillyLaker24, May 04, 2013 - 07:34 AM.